Mystery Pipit from Hong Kong

I have been trying to identify one of the pipits that I photgraphed in Hong Kong on a recent trip, on Oct 19, 2002. The location is These are taken in "Long Valley" in Hong Kong.  This is a garden area. I have 2 different identifications of the bird.

Below are two photographs taken of the "Mystery Pipit". The photos are taken through a 20x scope with a Nikon 4500 camera.

Taken 2002 Oct 19 1:52 PM

Taken 2002 Oct 19 1:52 PM


The identifications received from the Fontiers of Field Identification are:


david@cahlander.com
Last update 2002 Nov 6